Print to PDF
  • About Us
  • Privacy
  • Contact Us

Contact Lens Update

Clinical Insights Based in Current Research

Search Our Site

  • Home
  • Browse Past Issues
  • Resource Library
  • Back to Basics
  • Useful Links
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Summary: Report of the Clinical Trial Design and Outcomes Subcommittee

April 28th, 2014

Download PDF

Marc Schulze is a clinical scientist at the Centre for Contact Lens Research, in the School of Optometry at the University of Waterloo, Canada. 

Foulks G, Chalmers R, Keir N, Woods CA, Simpson T, Lippman R, Gleason W, Schaumbert DA, Willcox MDP, Jalbert I. The TFOS International Workshop on Contact Lens Discomfort: Report of the Subcommittee on Clinical Trial Design and Outcomes. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science 2013 54:TFOS157-TFOS182.

A review of the peer-reviewed literature found that most clinical trials on the subject of “contact lens discomfort” (31 total) were designed to compare study products and not tailored to investigate the nature and etiology of contact lens discomfort. A further review of the literature was performed to identify potential outcomes measures to describe contact lens discomfort, including staining, hyperemia, tear film changes, vision ocular sensitivity and contact lens surfaces. The objective of the subcommittee on clinical trial design and outcomes was to propose appropriate clinical trial designs and suitable outcome measures for clinical research.

Guidelines for future research
The committee reported that clinical trials should be designed with the following criteria as guidelines:

  • The study should be prospective, randomized and double-masked, and may have other specifications (e.g. contra-lateral or cross-over design) depending on the research question(s).
  • The study should have a fixed design (e.g. fixed sample size) rather than an adaptive design (e.g. sample size may be modified as study progresses).
  • Appropriate entry criteria and adequate sample size are crucial.
  • Although not always possible, masking of investigator and participants is critical and should always be attempted, even if it means assigning different researchers for contact lens assessment and ocular physiology.
  • The research team should identify and avoid potential sources of bias in study design and data collection.

Questionnaires
The committee was unable to recommend a specific questionnaire for measuring contact lens discomfort, acknowledging that the CLDEQ-8 is the best option currently available, but not ideal. More work is required to develop distinct questionnaires geared toward different types of contact lenses.

The most suitable outcome measures to describe differences in contact lens discomfort or between groups are yet to be determined. The ideal outcome measure should be objective, valid, standardized and measurable with minimal bias.

The committee also recommended the use of technology (e.g. smartphones) for recording of data, because it is easy to use and allows for accurate tracking of time and therefore timely collection of data.

Overall, a better understanding of the prevalence and incidence of contact lens discomfort is required before any interventional studies should be performed. The committee recommended conducting basic clinical trials in order to get a better understanding of the outcome measures related to contact lens discomfort and the levels of clinically meaningful change for these measures.

For further details, please refer to The TFOS International Workshop on Contact Lens Discomfort: Report of the Clinical Trial Design and Outcomes Subcommittee.

Issues

  • Multifocal Contact Lenses
  • Artificial Tears: An Update
  • Myopia: New Evidence and Best Practices
  • Neuropathic Pain
  • Specialty Rigid Lenses
  • Contact lens compliance
  • Pandemic update
  • Digital Devices and Dry Eye: A Growing Issue
  • The long and short of axial length
  • Using BCLA CLEAR with your patients
  • Helping your patients through allergy season
  • Getting the measure of meibomian glands
  • 2020: An extraordinary year
  • Scleral lens update
  • A dose of myopia
  • New news since TFOS DEWS II
  • COVID-19 Special Edition
  • Material considerations
  • Putting dry eye theory into practice
  • Getting started with Ortho-K
  • Infiltrates – an update
  • Staining
  • Myopia matters: Summarising the IMI reports
  • Lids and contact lenses
  • Myths
  • Revisiting patient compliance
  • Contact Lenses & Kids
  • Interprofessional Collaboration
  • Digital eye strain
  • New Dry Eye Technology
  • Update on Presbyopia
  • Taking stock of dry eye disease: DEWS II
  • Scleral Lenses
  • Pain and Sensation
  • Lab measurements in clinical practice
  • Control of pediatric myopia
  • Nutrition
  • Rethinking contact lens deposits
  • Extended wear
  • Daily Disposables
  • Eyelash Mites (Demodex)
  • Outsmarting bacteria with new technology
  • Youth and contact lenses
  • Sports Vision
  • Ocular effects of UV radiation from the sun
  • Eyelid Conditions
  • Makeup: Impact on ocular health
  • Myopia Control – Update 2014
  • The Growing Prevalence of Myopia
  • Cosmetic contact lenses
  • Contact lens discomfort – The essentials
  • Technology and contact lens research
  • It's A Question of Comfort
  • Contact lens materials
  • Let's talk about SICS
  • Conjunctival Controversies
  • Kids & Contact Lenses
  • One-day silicone hydrogel lenses
  • Solutions
  • Spotlight on Scleral lenses
  • Drug delivery via contact lenses
  • Ocular allergies
  • Reducing lens case contamination
  • Dry eye and meibomium gland dysfunction
  • Myopia Control
  • Presbyopia
  • Compliance and non-compliance
  • Lens care
  • Celebrating 50 years of contact lenses

Looking for another article?

Alcon coopervision Johnson&Johnson Vision Care

Newsletter Sign-Up

Sign-up for and start receiving our newsletter.

Site Map

  • Home
  • Browse Past Issues
    • Editorial
    • Feature Article
    • Clinical Insight
    • Conference Highlights
  • Resource Library
  • Back to Basics
  • Useful Links
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
© 2023 Contact Lens Update