• About Us
  • Privacy
  • Contact Us

Contact Lens Update

Clinical Insights Based in Current Research

Search Our Site

  • Home
  • Browse Past Issues
  • Resource Library
  • Back to Basics
  • Useful Links
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Conference Highlights

Correlates of Subjective and Objective Measures of Ocular Discomfort

April 28th, 2014
Subam Basuthkar recently graduated with a PhD in Vision Science from the University of Waterloo, Centre for Contact Lens Research. Her research interests include: ocular discomfort with contact lenses, sensory and non-sensory pain processing, and pain measurement.

Download the poster (.pdf), which was originally shared at the Annual Meeting of The Association for Research in Vision and Opthalmology (ARVO), 2011.


Subam Basuthkar Sundar Rao1, Trefford Simpson2A, Desmond Fonn2B
1Optometry/Vision Science, CCLR University of Waterloo, Toronto, ON, Canada;
ASchool of Optometry,
BSchool of Optometry-CCLR,
2University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON, Canada.

Purpose: To study the correlation of objective and subjective measurements of ocular discomfort.
Methods: 27 participants were enrolled for the study. Soft (HEMA) contact lenses of eight different lens designs varying by base curve and diameter were fitted on all participants. The study was conducted on two separate days with four lenses randomly assigned on each day. Subjective measurements of discomfort were obtained using numerical rating scales. The assigned contact lens was fitted on one eye and the equivalent corneal discomfort was matched on the fellow eye using stimuli delivered from a computer controlled pneumatic Belmonte esthesiometer. Corneal mechanical threshold was first measured using the ascending method of limits and after contact lens insertion, the match of discomfort with contact lens was set using the esthesiometer. Pearson product moment correlation was used to correlate the objective esthesiometer matches to the subjective ratings of discomfort reported by each participant.
Results: 13 out of 27 participants showed statistically significant correlation between objective and subjective discomfort (correlation ranged from 0.71 to 0.89). The remaining subjects showed a correlation between -0.04 to 0.70, which were not statistically significant. In the group of participants that showed a good correlation, subjective discomfort ranged from 14.23± 12.39 to 59.23± 26.99 for the most comfortable to the least comfortable lens with corresponding esthesiometer values between 40.38± 17.71 to 59.23± 26.99 ml/min. For the group with poor correlation, the subjective ratings were 21.43± 22.74 to 56.43± 25.38 for the most comfortable to the least comfortable lens. The corresponding esthesiometer values were 52.36± 25.78 to 56.43± 25.38 ml/min. The range of ethesiometer intensities used by the participants in poorly correlated group was insufficient to cover the subjective discomfort reported by them.
Conclusions: Subjective ratings of ocular discomfort can be scaled by corneal esthesiometry in a selective group of people. In the subset of subjects with poorer correlations, perhaps the pneumatic mechanical stimulus was too localized and specific to match the complex sensations experienced while wearing contact lenses. Proper training in esthesiometry procedure might ensure a better correlation. However, there is also a group of subjects who are poor at making judgments about ocular comfort. So special sensory panels should be used when ocular discomfort is the primary outcome.

Related Articles

  • April 28, 2014

    Contact lens discomfort solved through appropriate choice of lenses

  • April 28, 2014

    Summary: 2013 Report of the Workshop on Contact Lens Discomfort

  • April 28, 2014

    Correlates of Subjective and Objective Measures of Ocular Discomfort

  • April 24, 2014

    Overview: 2013 report from the Tear Film & Ocular Surface Society’s Workshop on Contact Lens Discomfort

Issues

  • Multifocal Contact Lenses
  • Artificial Tears: An Update
  • Myopia: New Evidence and Best Practices
  • Neuropathic Pain
  • Specialty Rigid Lenses
  • Contact lens compliance
  • Pandemic update
  • Digital Devices and Dry Eye: A Growing Issue
  • The long and short of axial length
  • Using BCLA CLEAR with your patients
  • Helping your patients through allergy season
  • Getting the measure of meibomian glands
  • 2020: An extraordinary year
  • Scleral lens update
  • A dose of myopia
  • New news since TFOS DEWS II
  • COVID-19 Special Edition
  • Material considerations
  • Putting dry eye theory into practice
  • Getting started with Ortho-K
  • Infiltrates – an update
  • Staining
  • Myopia matters: Summarising the IMI reports
  • Lids and contact lenses
  • Myths
  • Revisiting patient compliance
  • Contact Lenses & Kids
  • Interprofessional Collaboration
  • Digital eye strain
  • New Dry Eye Technology
  • Update on Presbyopia
  • Taking stock of dry eye disease: DEWS II
  • Scleral Lenses
  • Pain and Sensation
  • Lab measurements in clinical practice
  • Control of pediatric myopia
  • Nutrition
  • Rethinking contact lens deposits
  • Extended wear
  • Daily Disposables
  • Eyelash Mites (Demodex)
  • Outsmarting bacteria with new technology
  • Youth and contact lenses
  • Sports Vision
  • Ocular effects of UV radiation from the sun
  • Eyelid Conditions
  • Makeup: Impact on ocular health
  • Myopia Control – Update 2014
  • The Growing Prevalence of Myopia
  • Cosmetic contact lenses
  • Contact lens discomfort – The essentials
  • Technology and contact lens research
  • It's A Question of Comfort
  • Contact lens materials
  • Let's talk about SICS
  • Conjunctival Controversies
  • Kids & Contact Lenses
  • One-day silicone hydrogel lenses
  • Solutions
  • Spotlight on Scleral lenses
  • Drug delivery via contact lenses
  • Ocular allergies
  • Reducing lens case contamination
  • Dry eye and meibomium gland dysfunction
  • Myopia Control
  • Presbyopia
  • Compliance and non-compliance
  • Lens care
  • Celebrating 50 years of contact lenses

Looking for another article?

Alcon coopervision Johnson&Johnson Vision Care

Newsletter Sign-Up

Sign-up for and start receiving our newsletter.

Site Map

  • Home
  • Browse Past Issues
    • Editorial
    • Feature Article
    • Clinical Insight
    • Conference Highlights
  • Resource Library
  • Back to Basics
  • Useful Links
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
© 2023 Contact Lens Update